Artículo original
Vol. 1 | Num. 1 (Eng.)
28 min
Cómo citar
Métricas
59
Visualizaciones
2
Descargas
Compartir
Compartir
Resumen (EN)
Palabras clave (EN):
The use of negative pressure therapy (NPT) is a widely adopted option in the field of plastic surgery; its main application is the treatment of complex wounds, which are those with healing difficulties due to factors such as the presence of devitalized tissue, infection, exposure of vital structures (tendons, bones, vessels, nerves), patient comorbidities, or previous treatments (1). These wounds pose a challenge for clinical management, as they can lead to serious complications, such as sepsis, amputation, or death, in addition to negatively affecting the patient's quality of life (2).
In these cases, negative pressure therapy acts as a temporary management until skin coverage becomes possible (3); by providing immobilization, eliminating fluids, preventing the formation of hematomas, and contributing to infection control (4). Physiopathologically, it promotes the expression of proangiogenic and proliferative factors, modulating the inflammatory response by decreasing TNF-alpha and IL-6, promoting the formation of granulation tissue and blood flow (5).
The negative pressure system consists of several elements, each of which individually plays a role in modulating healing. These elements include a semi-occlusive dressing, a polyurethane foam (GranuFoam; KCI Medical) with a resting pore size of 400 to 600 microns, hydrophobic, and a vacuum pump with typical suction forces of 125 mmHg (6). One of the disadvantages of polyurethane sponges is the difficulty in placing them on circumferential wounds of extremities (4), and the growth of granulation tissue causes pain and tissue damage during removal (7). Therefore, for wounds exposing tendon, bone, or nerve tissues, the use of white polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) sponge (WhiteFoam, KCI Medical, San Antonio, Tex) is indicated; it is hydrophilic and non-adherent with a pore size of 0.06 to 0.27 mm (8), which protects the structures to prevent desiccation (5). Jelonet is a mesh gauze made of cotton fabric impregnated with soft paraffin that forms a protective layer over structures, allowing the passage of exudate and air while maintaining a moist environment. It adapts to the wound bed and facilitates dressing changes with less pain (7), due to the fact that granulation tissue does not grow into the gauze (9), making it preferred for ischemic and granulated wounds, where hypoperfusion is less pronounced, being ideal for wounds with questionable vascularization or ischemic risk (10), and it is also much more useful in irregular wounds (11). Despite these advantages, there are no studies on its use as a dressing in negative pressure therapy to protect osteotendinous tissues, which is why the objective of this study is to compare the white polyvinyl alcohol sponge and Jelonet in wounds with bone or tendon exposure that require wound bed preparation for skin coverage.
There is also a very significant difference in cost; on the market, a piece of Jelonet measuring 10x10 cm costs eighty Mexican pesos (four dollars), while a small white sponge measuring 10x7.5 cm costs eight hundred Mexican pesos (forty dollars).
The main objective of this study is to compare polyvinyl alcohol sponge and paraffin gauze in complex wounds with bone or tendon exposure using negative pressure therapy for wound bed preparation.
A non-randomized comparative experimental study was conducted prospectively at the General Zone Hospital of La Paz, Baja California Sur, between January and December 2023. The study protocol was approved by the Ethics and Research Committee of the hospital, and informed consent was obtained from all patients.
The inclusion criteria were: patients over 18 years old, with complex wounds exposing tendons and/or bones that required negative pressure therapy (TPN).
The exclusion criteria were: patients with contraindications for negative pressure therapy (NPT), such as active bleeding, fistulas, osteomyelitis, cancer, coagulopathies, or pregnancy; patients with allergy or hypersensitivity to any of the study materials; patients who did not agree to participate or who dropped out of treatment.
Description of the procedure
The procedure was performed after cleaning, surgical debridement of the wound, and hemostasis; the dressing was then applied: for group 1, the white polyvinyl alcohol sponge (WhiteFoam, KCI Medical, San Antonio, Tex) and for group 2, the paraffin gauze (Jelonet Smith & Nephew), specifically covering the tendon or bony structures. A polyurethane granufoam sponge was applied over both dressings to cover the entire wound, and was finally sealed with a semipermeable transparent dressing. Negative pressure therapy was conducted with suction of 125 mmHg, in continuous mode for the first 48 hours and then intermittently at 3 min on-3 min off, with high intensity. Dressings were changed every 6-8 days until completing 4 changes or achieving adequate coverage of the bony and/or tendon structures with sufficient granulation tissue to perform a split-thickness skin graft or to cover with a skin flap upon reaching the maximum of 4 changes. Measurements of the wound area, granulation tissue, and noble tissue (tendons and/or bones) exposed at the beginning and end of treatment were carried out using the application imitoMeasure – Measure Wounds (imito AG). Figure 1.
The following variables were evaluated at the beginning and end of the treatment: wound area; granulation tissue area, healthy tissue area; infection diagnosed through microbiological culture, amount of exudate in milliliters based on the containers of the negative pressure system, pain during changes assessed using a visual analog scale (VAS) from 0 to 10 classified into 6 groups 0-1 no pain, 2-3 mild pain, 4-5 moderate pain, 6-7 strong pain, 8-9 very strong pain, and 10 extreme pain, as well as change time, number of changes, and the presence of local complications such as bleeding, osteomyelitis, infection of the flap or graft, necrosis or partial or total loss of the flap or graft, time elapsed from wound treatment to skin coverage, comorbidities, and costs of the dressings used as primary dressings (polyvinyl alcohol sponge and jelonet).
The statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 29.0. Normality tests (Kolmogorov-Smirnov) were used to verify the application conditions for parametric tests. Student's t-tests for independent and paired samples were employed to compare the means of the quantitative variables between and within groups, respectively. Chi-square tests were used to compare the frequencies of qualitative variables between groups. A statistical significance level of p < 0.05 was considered.
Twelve patients with complex wounds requiring negative pressure therapy (NPT) were included in the study, of which 6 were assigned to the polyvinyl alcohol sponge group and 6 to the paraffin gauze group. The characteristics of the patients, both general and specific to each group, are shown in Table 1.
25% of the patients had an initial positive wound culture; by the end, there were negative results in 100%; an average exudate of 1633 ml was observed. The mean duration of changes in negative pressure therapy was 6.83 days, with an average of changes of 3.5 times; the mean duration of treatment until skin coverage was 32.9 days. The most affected anatomical area was the foot at 33.3%, followed by the hand and wrist at 16.7%, while the elbow and leg were involved at 8.3%.
The paired T-test showed statistically significant differences for the wound area, granulation tissue area, and for the initial and final osteotendinous exposure area for the paraffin gauze group (Table 2). On the other hand, no statistically significant differences were found for the polyvinyl alcohol sponge group for the 6 main compared variables (Tables 3).
The chi-square test did not show significant differences for the qualitative variables of sex, infection, pain, anatomical area, and comorbidities (Table 4).
The costs showed a statistically significant difference for the paraffin gauze dressing with a p of 0.002. The average cost in the Paraffin Gauze group was 396 Mexican pesos (19 dollars) and in the White Sponge group it was 18,485 Mexican pesos (891 dollars).
Negative pressure acts to prepare the wound bed until skin coverage is possible. It was generally well tolerated, and no complications were reported with the use of dressings for both polyvinyl alcohol sponge and paraffin gauze, in relation to what was reported by Campbell et Al (7).
Huang et al. (12) state that polyurethane foam is better than polyvinyl alcohol foam in promoting wound angiogenesis and granulation tissue proliferation, which correlates with our results where we found statistically significant differences between the use of paraffin gauze and polyurethane foam. These differences may be due to two factors: 1- The white polyvinyl alcohol sponge has smaller pores, as mentioned by Yusuf et al. (13). This requires a greater range of negative pressure to generate the traction forces that influence cellular mitosis, resulting in fibroblast proliferation, as noted by Glass et al. (5). Therefore, when using PVA sponge, negative pressures greater than 40 kPa, equivalent to 300 mmHg, must be applied to achieve maximum exudate transit from the wound and to prolong the use of the vacuump dressing, as mentioned by Maier et al. (14). In our study, the negative pressure used was 125 mmHg, which is in line with that used in other studies (10, 11, 15) that led to a similar reduction in wound area, demonstrating that gauze and foam are equally effective in administering negative pressure. It is important to mention that the negative pressure system used, V.A.C (KCI), provides a maximum of 200 mmHg. 2.- The polyvinyl alcohol sponge is hydrophilic, an important characteristic for preventing desiccation of vital structures, however, with suboptimal negative pressure, it would produce an excess of exudate at the wound level and alongside an increase in bacterial proliferation, which stimulates the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-1, 6, and TNF-alpha) with an increase in matrix metalloproteinases and a decrease in growth factor, these cascades inhibit the formation of granulation tissue (5, 13). Unlike paraffin gauze (Jelonet), which has larger pores and is hydrophobic, promoting the expression of pro-angiogenic and proliferative factors that modulate the inflammatory response with a decrease in TNF-alpha and IL-6. This eliminates the excess tissue exudate and maintains a favorable microenvironment to prevent tissue desiccation (5), which reduces bacterial proliferation (13).
Some limitations of this study were that the sample size was small, which could limit the statistical power to detect differences between the groups. Additionally, it was not blinded, which could introduce some bias in the evaluation of the variables. Finally, the study did not include a control group without negative pressure therapy, which prevented the comparison of the efficacy and safety of negative pressure therapy with the dressings used and with conventional treatment for complex wounds.
This study compared the use of polyvinyl alcohol sponge and paraffin gauze as primary dressings for the protection of tendons and bones as well as the preparation of the bed in complex wounds using negative pressure therapy. The results showed that paraffin gauze results in a greater reduction of the wound, with a larger area of granulation tissue and greater coverage of noble tissues, at a lower cost and without complications, with statistically significant differences, making it a treatment option. These findings should be substantiated with larger sample size randomized controlled trials and long-term follow-up.
| General characteristics | Number |
|---|---|
| Number of patients | 12 |
| Male | 9 (75%) |
| Female | 3 (25%) |
| Age | 27.67 (±6.746) |
| Comorbidities | DM2 (16.7%) HAS (8.3%) |
| Initial Wound Area (cm2) | 183.9 (±321.9) |
| Final Wound Area (cm2) | 163.1(±313.1) |
| Initial Granulation Area (cm2) | 7.5 (±17) |
| Final Granulation Area (cm2) | 67.9(±153.4) |
| Initial Noble Tissue Area (cm2) | 31.1 (±32.9) |
| Final Noble Tissue Area (cm2) | 18.1(±31.9) |
| Group 1 (polyvinyl alcohol sponge) | |
| Age (mean) | 26.33 (±5.125) |
| Sex | M 4 (66.7%) F 2 (33.3%) |
| Initial Wound Area (cm2) | 314.21 (±432.39) |
| Final Wound Area (cm2) | 300.16 (±412.53) |
| Initial Granulation Area (cm2) | 13.91 (±23.25) |
| Final Granulation Area (cm2) | 109.83 (±217.11) |
| Initial Noble Tissue Area (cm2) | 41.35 (±44.68) |
| Final Noble Tissue Area (cm2) | 35.91(±38.51) |
| Infection (%) | 1 (16.7) |
| Exudate (ml) | 2583.33 (±2973.49) |
| Pain during change (VAS 0-10) | No pain 3 (50%) little pain 3 (50%) |
| Days to change | 7 (±0.894) |
| Complications (%) | 0 |
| Time until skin coverage | 28.83 (±4.215) |
| Skin coverage | Graft 2 (33.3%) flap 4 (66.7%) |
| Costs | 18485.5 (±3180.39) |
| Number of changes | 3.50 (±0.548) |
| Group 2 (paraffin gauze Jelonet) | |
| Age (mean) | 29 (±8.343) |
| Sex | M 5 (83.3%) F 1 (16.7%) |
| Initial Wound Area (cm2) | 53.66 (±17.47) |
| Final Wound Area (cm2) | 26.08(±20.90) |
| Initial Granulation Area (cm2) | 1.25(±1.08) |
| Final Granulation Area (cm2) | 25.96 (±20.90) |
| Initial Noble Tissue Area (cm2) | 20.91 (±11.99) |
| Final Noble Tissue Area (cm2) | 0.36 (±0.58) |
| Infection (%) | 2 (33.3) |
| Exudate (ml) | 683.33(±318.85) |
| Pain during change (VAS 0-10) | No pain 3 (50%) little pain 3 (50%) |
| Days to change | 6.67 (±0.516) |
| Complications (%) | 0 |
| Time until skin coverage | 37(±13.66) |
| Skin coverage | Graft 6 (100%) |
| Costs | 396 (±55.77) |
| Number of changes | 3.67 (±0.516) |
Explorar
Artículos
Volúmenes
Sobre la revista
Más leídos
Revista Internacional de Reparación Tisular y Heridas
Revista Internacional de Reparación Tisular y Heridas
Revista Internacional de Reparación Tisular y Heridas
Revista Internacional de Reparación Tisular y Heridas
Revista Internacional de Reparación Tisular y Heridas